The Patient

December 14, 2012 — 6 Comments

PatientWhen I was a child, my parents were very friendly with their doctor who was an internist (someone who did medical training in internal medicine or general medicine for adults). Because he was a family friend, he agreed to start seeing me as a patient when I was about 12 years old. He was warm and friendly and took a long time to talk with me in his office before examining me. He did very few tests and almost never drew my blood.

I remember those days fondly but they are long gone. My childhood doctor had far fewer tools at his fingertips and far less medical knowledge than we have today. Patients had very little access to the scant medical literature that was available. We put our trust in our doctors because they knew more than we did.

Today, things are very different. Medical knowledge and technology have grown dramatically. We now know that in most medical situations, there is no single, right answer. As much as we might like our doctor to tell us the right decision, there really is no right answer for everybody. My doctor can help me figure out what is right for me by considering my values and preferences and helping me to understand the scientific evidence. This is the essence of the Care Triad.

Here’s an example. The research (for now) is pretty clear that there is no difference in survival if a woman with breast cancer that is caught early has a mastectomy (complete removal of the breast) or a lumpectomy (removal of the tumor) followed by radiation. One woman might opt for a mastectomy because she feels strongly that she wants to be sure that all the cancer is removed. Another woman might opt for a lumpectomy with radiation because she can’t stand the thought of losing her breast. Both decisions are “right” based on the existing medical knowledge and the values and preferences of the individual woman making the decision. Asking your doctor to choose your care for you is like asking your haircutter to pick your hairstyle for you – you want your haircutter to provide some suggestions or recommendations but not to decide unilaterally what is best for you.

We, as patients, need to participate in our own care to make sure our healthcare decisions are right for us. There are numerous movements focused on the voice of the patient – patient empowerment, patient experience, patient centered care, shared decisionmaking to name a few. I will try to avoid using these terms since it can get confusing to figure out how they all work together. The important thing is to remember that healthcare is about caring for the patient.

I don’t mind the word “patient”; many people prefer “consumer” or “client” or “person” but I think we can all understand that a patient is a person who is in contact with the healthcare system.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. The Doctor - Care Triad - December 20, 2012

    […] Things are different now. It is impossible to keep up-to-date with all of the medical advances and there are now a huge number of tests available to diagnose diseases. No one person can manage all of the complexities of care so doctors have become more specialized. Medicine needs to become more of a team sport – where specialists work together as a team to help the patient. And doctors need to accept the roles of new types of care providers as team members such as physician assistants and nurse practitioners who may be especially suited to provide routine care. We also now recognize that physical therapy, occupational therapy and nutrition are integral elements of care and that stress management, acupuncture, weight loss, health coaching and numerous other interventions can improve health in certain situations. In addition to being able to work as part of a team and help coordinate the team, doctors need to recognize that the most important member of the team is the patient. […]

  2. Technology is bad...and good - Care Triad - March 6, 2013

    […] believe strongly that the relationship between a doctor and a patient can lead to healing by itself. And there is little question that doctors have less time to listen […]

  3. Communication, Innovation and Organization - Care Triad - September 19, 2013

    […] lots of overlap with each other but together they can enhance the relationships between doctors and patients and help get the evidence about what treatments work best to the people who need […]

  4. Patient centered billing - Care Triad - September 19, 2013

    […] have to say that the medical care my daughter received was focused on the patient but the billing department did not have the patient in mind at […]

  5. More on technology (and communication) - Care Triad - September 19, 2013

    […] don’t listen carefully to what patients and their families are saying. They forget that patients are the experts about their own symptoms. Doctors have a tendency to get locked into thinking about […]

  6. Are screening tests good for you? | Care TriadAre screening tests good for you? - Care Triad - January 2, 2014

    […] downsides are much less obvious than you might think. When you have a disease, you need to decide which treatment is best for you. The decision to get screened for a disease is also personal. The problem is that in order to make […]

Leave a Reply

Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>